Discussion Board: Bread Givers
The following discussion board was created as a place for current Honors English Four students to share their thoughts and experiences reading Bread Givers. Students are required to post their thoughts and experiences twice a week throughout the research paper process.
7 comments:
Meera Patel
When asked to pick a research paper novel, I will admit, I left it for the last minute and hoped I could pick one easily and quickly. I sat down to look through the options and realized that I would have trouble selecting a novel that I might enjoy writing about. I happened upon the title Bread Givers and read through the summary and background. It seemed like the only novel on the list that would not prove completely depressing. I realize now, how incorrectly I guessed. It proved entirely riveting instead! In the past week I have fallen behind on my reading schedule, but will still finish the novel on time as I have already read more than half of the book. Whenever I have a free period or little homework to do, I find I can read about thirty pages of the novel easily. The plot has me so captivated; I find it hard to miss a single word.
Reb Smolinsky spends every waking moment reading holy books and preaching to his wife and four daughters about religion. He ignores the concerns of his family and explains everything through religion. He uses it as an excuse for his behavior towards his family and as a means of escaping the world. His four girls search for work at the beginning of the novel because they alone, bring in the income to their family. Bessie, the eldest, works to support her family night and day, carrying the burdens of everyone in the household. Mashah on the other hand, cares solely about her looks and spends any money she makes on herself. Sara, the narrator, tells readers of her family’s struggles as she sees them.
When Bessie falls for a man called Berel Bernstein, she brings him home only to see him shooed from the house by her father who deems him unworthy. He wants his daughters wed to men with respectable professions to show the neighbors how great of a family he heads. Any signs of love the girls portray Reb smothers immediately. He looks for men to wed Mashah and Fania, but leaves Bessie out of the picture. Why? She earns him the most money and losing her would mean losing his relaxed lifestyle. He does not work, yet gets the most food and the credit for keeping the family from starvation. Bessie swallows her grievances and works without getting anything in return. Her youngest sister Sara, however, witnesses her pain and looks to help her sister in any way she can. By giving the role of narrator to the youngest sister, the author, Anzia Yezierska, creates a window for the reader to see every ounce of suffering that the Smolinsky girls face.
Every trick Reb Smolinsky pulls and every ignorant word he says get my emotions roaring as I read the novel. I yell at him in my head and wish I could open his eyes to the nastiness in the way he treats his daughters. I think of my own life and remember that I can see every unfair aspect of it amplified in the lives of the Smolinsky girls. Because the novel kept me thinking about the unfair treatment of the women described in the story, Feminism seemed like the most logical literary school to research. Even the smallest amount of research into the school has me thinking about the various ways in which to approach the research paper. Any feminist critic would undoubtedly focus on the damaged relationship between father and daughters in Bread Givers and underline how Reb takes advantage of the work his girls do and the money they earn him. Each girl has her own strengths but feels them stifled by her father’s controlling, arrogant nature. A critic in this school might analyze the roles of women and men especially those within an immigrant family such as the Smolinskys. Every page screams feminism, and has forced me to read with a highlighter in order to underline the many quotes that either prove a point mulling around in my head, or simply move me.
I finished Bread Givers by Anzia Yezierska. At first the story of a young girl trying to abandon tradition and thrive for her own future interested me. During the first half of the book, the book bored me by its repetitive plot which mostly included the old Jewish father’s brutal abuse on his family and his obsessive faith in religion that only deprives the family. But starting from the narrator’s escape from her father to her success of becoming an independent, educated teacher with a husband who truly loves her, the book appealed to me with the narrator’s young American dream. I enjoy reading the book because Sara’s road to independence reminds me of my family’s struggle to start a new life in America and my struggle to adapt to this new environment when I first came here. As a younger generation, we share the same conflicts with traditions from the old world and our parents’ stubborn ideals, and long to seek autocracy. The book focuses on the roles of women, religion, and money. The title “Bread Givers” creates the irony where the traditionally accepted role of men as wage earners of the family belongs to the women in the story. The father, who views himself as the holy man who will support his family by devoting his time to studying and preaching the Torah, tortures the family by marrying his daughters to men they do not love and giving away the money to charity even though he is in extreme poverty. Throughout the novel, money and material assets also performed as a symbol that determines the destiny of the characters and their relationships with each other.
The book suits many different literary criticism approaches, the most obvious being feminist. A feminist should focus on women’s roles in a Jewish society and how gender determines the destiny of the characters. The analyst should especially focus on Sara’s struggle to become a teacher due to her gender. If attempting historical approach, a reader should research the historical background of the novel as well as the author’s biography and connections among them. For example, the reader might find that the author’s early life as a poor Jewish immigrant in ghetto New York who ran away against her father’s will similar to the plot and setting of the book. The women’s rights movement and the living conditions of immigrants in America will also be important parts of the background. A New Critic, however, would only focus on the text and the literary devices used, such as the irony in which the Torah’s says that women are nothing without men, but the Smolinsky women become nothing because of the man.
Harrison Kaye
Blog Post #1 Part 1
I am reading “Bread Givers” by Anzia Yezierska. The novel is about a young Jewish girl, Sarah, living in America with her old-fashioned Jewish parents. She has three older sisters who conform to their parents’ morals and values. However, Sarah does not have the same thought. Instead, as she sees her sisters go off to marry men their parents choose, Sarah decides she does not want her life chosen for her. Therefore, she leaves her parents’ house and goes to work and live on her own.
I had a reading schedule that had me reading one chapter each day that I had study hall. I thought this would be a good plan, but my other classes decided to interfere with that idea. I have found it easier to read two chapters each day, every other day. That way I can still get my work done for other classes and read along my schedule. I have enjoyed the book thus far because I have been able to connect with Sarah. My father grew up learning at a Yeshiva. This type of school teaches Hebrew lessons as well as American lessons that any school has. He learned a certain set of values that are stricter that today’s lifestyle. Every day I find myself battling with his old-fashioned ideas, but I find a way to make it work. That is one way that I differ from Sarah – I would never leave my parents until I was ready. And even then I would ask their opinion and listen to their advice.
I enjoy Yezierska’s use of Hebrew and Yiddish language because it makes the story more believable. I even recognize some of the words used in the novel from hearing my parents say them to me. I chuckle a little when I see the words which connect them to events in my life.
Harrison Kaye
Blog Post #1 Part 2
I have narrowed down my decision on which school of literary analysis to two: Feminism or Psychoanalytical. I have seen good scenes for both, but I am not sure I am more comfortable with yet. I am not much of a feminist but I understand the values that go along with the criticism and think that I can use it to show how Sarah is showing her independence as a woman and has every right to. On the other hand, I am taking AP Psychology so I know the concept of psychoanalysis fairly well and I think I could use three of the sisters as each part of the mind. Either way would work in my opinion, so I will decide that soon.
If I chose feminism, I would focus on Sarah because she is the only female character who rebels and believes in herself enough to be independent. Early in the novel she keeps her thoughts to herself when she sees her sisters being bossed around because it did not affect her personally. However, when her forceful father starts pushing her around, she cannot stand it. This would be a great example of how women have progressed over time and how the role of women has changed. In the mid-20th century, women were looked at as stay-at-home mothers who did chores and cooked. Now they are just as successful as men and have the same expectations. I could also use Sarah’s mother as a contrast to feminist ideals. While she does begin to speak up more, Sarah’s mother continuously takes her husband’s insulting language without further thought. This is because she was raised with the old-fashioned ideas and therefore believes that her role in the house is only to cook and clean.
With the psychoanalytical approach, I would use the sisters Bessie, Mashah and Fania Smolinsky. Each sister brings one part of the id-ego-superego trio in Freud’s theory. To start, Mashah would easily be the id. She ignores her family’s needs and only thinks of herself. When she earns any money, no matter how small the amount, she immediately spends it on herself rather than saving it to contribute to the family. On the other hand, Fania is the “goody-two-shoes” of the family. When Fania is passionate about a man who her father does not approve, she gives in without much fight and tries to adapt to her father’s selection. This does not work out for her as is the case in many situations like hers. Bessie is the mediator of the sisters. She sticks around the longest of the three because she brings in the most money for the family and she also does the most chores at home. Her father decides to save her for last to find a husband so she can provide for the family longer.
Sharon Sidhu
At the very mentioning of a research paper, I initially felt disinterested and knew I would dread the lengthy and, as previously experienced, boring process of the research paper. Choosing a novel was quite the task. I thoroughly read through the packet of novels and came across Bread Givers, written by Anzia Yezierska, a novel that appealed to me greatly. It was then when I realized that this research paper would be less dreadful then previous papers I have written. Although, I must admit that even then, I am not up to date with my original reading schedule, but have adjusted it accordingly to meet the March 4th deadline.
Instantly, from page one, Bread Givers proved itself of not being the typical monotonous research novel of the past. As a young daughter of an immigrant father, I am able to relate to the Smolinksy girls, which allowed me to connect with the novel as a whole. The novel opens up in the heart of a conflict within a family struggling to make a living for themselves, with most of the burden in the hands of the the four daughters of Reb Smolinsky, Bessie, Mashah, Fania and the narrator, Sara. In the beginning, Reb Smolinsky seemed to be the innocent holy father, always praying for the basic well being of his family, but as the novel progressed, it seems quite clear that Reb has another agenda. He appears content with the conditions his family and him live by, as he contributes nothing to family, financially, and as the man of the family, or head, receives the equivalent of five star accommodations in that household. Yezierska created irony by flipping the basic stereotypical household roles in this novel, as the "bread givers" are normally expected to be the men of the family, whereas in this novel, the women are the only bread givers. Chasing the American Dream seemed to be a theme I noticed in this novel as well. All the daughters want is fortune, for a comfortable lifestyle, nicely decorated home, and of course love. But, of course, Reb does not restrain to voice his opinions on every decision the girls, or even his wife, attempts to make. I knew from after only the first chapter of this novel that the role of women and men is being portrayed as very unequal, mostly due to the foundation of the Jewish religion, that Reb strictly follows. Because of this reason, it was obvious that the most suiting literary school for this novel is feminism. The novel opened up introducing the patriarchal nature of the household, which all members subconsciously abide by. Any audience, male or female, taking a feminist approach while reading this novel will easily notice the conflict between Reb and his four daughters, which stems from his resentment of not having a son who can pray for him after his death. Any feminist would catch a key point in this novel, which is introduced in the first chapter, that is that the Jewish religion states that women only make it into heaven if they live a life dedicated to creating a comfortable and convenient life for the men in their life. Gender issues and disparities are apparent in all different areas in the novel, mainly stemming from the background of the family, being backwards, immigrants and above all, Jewish, the typical reasons women are generally not seen as equals. Feminist critics would mainly focus on those base reasons for lack of equality between Reb and the 4 daughters, and then apply it to the main conflicts and obstacles presented in the Bread Givers.
than*
Post a Comment