Discussion Board: The Foundation Trilogy
The following discussion board was created as a place for current Honors English Four students to share their thoughts and experiences reading The Foundation Trilogy. Students are required to post their thoughts and experiences twice a week throughout the research paper process.
2 comments:
Rowen Bahmer:
I finished the Foundation Trilogy over Christmas Break, though I have been debating as to whether or not I should read the other books in the series, and I have not reviewed it AT ALL. It is, however, a truly well written series, and I look forward to writing about it.
When I first delved into Foundation, I did not have very high expectations. I was expecting it to be somewhat annoying or boring, like the vast majority of the selections that one encounters in high school, disregarding the fact that I have read quite a bit of science fiction from the same time period, as well as Asimov’s “The Stars Like Dust,” all of which I enjoyed. Foundation was just as good as any of the other classics that I have read; it has a definable theme, a well built universe, and a very tight plot. The fact that it takes place over a monstrously huge expanse of time forces the reader to look at the “bigger picture” and acknowledge how various individuals can affect that picture. It encourages the reader to think about what’s going on. Like a mystery novel, it kept me on my seat wondering what would happen next, and I was pleased to discover when I had made a correct prediction about events in the story.
The actual overarching plot is extraordinarily simple. As the Galactic Empire is dying, mathmetician Hari Seldon engineers a plan through which he will guide mini-civilization through centuries of semi-barbarism in order to bring about a new, more developed empire. Seldon’s plan is thought to be ruined by the advent of an anomaly that his probabilities could not account for-a mutant called the Mule, who has the capacity to twist the emotions of human beings.
The next major event in the Foundation Epic is the Foundation’s choice to seek out and destroy the Second Foundation, a foundation of psychologists created by Seldon to account for such anomalies as the Mule and work around them, continuing to guide the Foundation to a “better world,” as it were. This is, of course, unsuccessful.
When examining the Foundation Trilogy, A culturalist would probably pay attention to Asimov’s use of nuclear technology, as well as it’s similarity to other science fiction novels of the time, such as the Lensman Series, which contains many similar elements, such as the importance of advanced thought. A New Critic would examine the repeated emphasis on progress, and advanced thought, as well as Asimov’s open criticism of putting the preservation of ancient knowledge of the research and discovery of new information. An Archetypal Critic would look at the Mule’s role as the foil of the story, the supplier of a conflict who’s end result is not predicted or assured.
Bharadwaj Ramachandran
I am currently on page 450 of the Foundation Trilogy, which places me almost exactly halfway through the second novel (slightly behind schedule). I find myself thoroughly enjoying Asimov’s Foundation trilogy, for very many reasons. The book possesses what readers of any age desire in a work of fiction: immersion. Asimov uses detail to engross the reader in the thoughts and actions of his many characters. Nevertheless, the structure of the trilogy’s plot amazes me just as much. The book details the story of the Seldon Plan, concocted by mathematician (and psychohistorian) Hari Seldon. Seldon foresees the destruction of the vast Galactic Empire, and creates a master plan to combat the 30,000 year “dark age” that that the Empire’s destruction would initiate. A society known as the Foundation serves as the vehicle for Seldon’s plan, which would decrease the duration of the dark age to a mere 1000 years. Each book in the trilogy consists of discrete sections, with each section detailing the exploits of a certain generation of Foundation members and their role in Seldon’s master plan.
Though the trilogy addresses such a vast array of topics, the book delves deepest into psychology and human nature. A psychological critic, such as Carl Jung, would note Asimov’s use of nuclear technology as a panacea for societal problems, which directly reflects the author’s perception of a nucleic society as ideal. A Freudian psychological critic would explain the thought behind Hari Seldon’s plan, claiming that the plan proved that humanity would always gravitate towards civility and its preservation.
Post a Comment