Discussion Board: The Jungle


The following discussion board was created as a place for current Honors English Four students to share their thoughts and experiences reading The Jungle. Students are required to post their thoughts and experiences twice a week throughout the research paper process.  



6 comments:

Gagan said...

Gagandeep Khera Part 1 of 2

Initially, this whole research paper process seemed nothing more than an extra burden academically. However, as I continue to delve into Upton Sinclair’s The Jungle, the burden I experience diminishes slightly more and more. Up until this very moment, I have read twenty-three chapters of this book, and am on pace to finish the remaining eight chapters by March. How can I begin to describe my experience with this novel? The answer is relatively simple: by telling you how much I love it.
The Jungle portrays the story of immigration, love, family, and the American Dream all in one shell. The story documents the harsh lives of Jurgis Rudkus and his Lithuanian family, newly immigrated to the Chicago Packingtown District. Initially, the family of about a dozen people comes to the U.S with the dreams of having their own home and earning their own riches. Nevertheless, the family soon realizes the grave they established for themselves by immigrating. Filled with optimism, the family decides to buy a home for themselves after first entering the workforce. Jurgis and his wife Ona have always dreamed of owning their own home and living in it with their family. The first time the family experiences deceit occurs when they buy their home. The real estate agent who sells the family their home ensures them that the home is new and has no previous owners. Of course, this turns out to be a complete sham and the family has bought an extremely old home with a new coat of paint. Furthermore, more and more clauses are enforced upon the family including the dreadful one of interest.

Gagan said...

Gagandeep Khera Part 2 of 2

As time goes on, the family encounters more and more problems. All the jobs that the family members hold no regard to hygiene what so ever. Often, Jurgis describes the horrors of the killing beds on which he toils day in and day out. Ultimately, Sinclair relies on grotesque imagery to describe working conditions. He describes the horrific practices of the meat industry, including even grinding up meat infected with tuberculosis, bacteria, and even human flesh! As bad as the working conditions may be, Jurgis works day in and day out. One day, Jurgis suffers a horrific injury at work and ends up losing his job and his livelihood. Ultimately, this strains his relationship with Ona and the rest of his family. Jurgis finds solace in one thing: his newborn son Antanas, who he names after his deceased grandfather (victim to the horrific working conditions of Packingtown). While laid off of work, Jurgis discovers something that changes the family’s state forever: his wife having a sexual relationship with her boss. She does so not because she wants to, but because she is forced to, or is faced with being laid off. In a fit of rage, Jurgis attacks the boss and is sent to jail. After coming out of jail and back to his family, Jurgis soon witnesses the death of his little Antanas and his wife Ona, which simply drive him to leave his world behind, and pursue a rural life of his own. However his sense of responsibility leads him back to Chicago and the never ending struggle to find a job.
In analyzing The Jungle Marxist analysts would focus on the working class that Jurgis and his family represent. Through his work, Upton Sinclair tried to elucidate the horrors that the working class, specifically immigrants, went through. Furthermore, Sinclair showed the disparity between the upper class and the lower class. He showed that while the rich got richer in this period, the poor got poorer. The upper class lived with luxuries, while the lower class lived in absolute misery. If this work were successful, which it indeed was during the former end of the 1900’s, workers would have been awarded better working conditions. Ultimately, this very book helped lead to the establishment of the FDA, which made food products much safer in the United States. Furthermore, Marxists would focus on the family oriented values that The Jungle emanated, while condemning the vice of greed. Ultimately, the work as a whole focuses on the role of family on one’s life. Up until this very point, his family has led Jurgis to an unhappy lifestyle, but I am absolutely certain that will change as the novel proceeds to end.

Unknown said...

Upton Sinclair’s Jungle focuses on revealing the horrors of the American meat packing industry. Though I am terribly behind on my reading schedule, only having read up to chapter seven, The Jungle has proven to be an exciting read thus far. Having learned about the Progressive Era of the early 1900s and thoroughly enjoying it, I decided to read The Jungle.

Despite having read only six chapters, I can clearly see that no one could have wrote this novel other than Upton Sinclair. His wit and mastery of the pen makes every page an enjoyable experience. Sinclair tells his tale by the following the lives of Jurgis Rudkus and his Lithuanian family in the Chicago Packingtown District. A man of great stature and size, Rudkus immediately finds work. Naïve and gullible like many other immigrants, Jurgis and his family believe in the ‘sugarcoated’ stories of America, which ultimately leave them susceptible to swindlers and corrupt political bosses. Upon receiving their first payment, the family makes plans to buy a home. In the end, the family buys the house, which they think is brand new. Not surprisingly, it turns out that the house is old with a new coat of paint.

Furthermore, the family soon discovers that they have to pay more than twelve dollars a month to keep their house. Because of the language barrier, the family did not realize that the deed which the signed forced them to pay interest, which increases the monthly payment to twenty dollars. The family soon learns from fellow neighbors and workers that deceit and corruption is common in Packingtown. It seems that individuals who wield power use it to pounce on the poor and prevent them from living the American Dream. In setting up Jurgis and his family to the traps that lay in Packingtown, Sinclair employs dramatic irony. For example, in letting the reader know that the family was signing a sham when they bought the house Sinclair underscores the vulnerability of immigrants in America. Though Sinclair has not really revealed the horrors of the meatpacking industry thus far, I can only help but imagine how he will continue to depict the wild jungle of Packingtown, where every man must fend for himself.

In analyzing Sinclair’s text through a specific critical lens, analysts could definitely pursue a Marxist approach. Marxist analysts would focus on the working class that Jurgis, his family, and the rest of the immigrants in Packingtown serve to represent in order to elucidate what class The Jungle claims to represent. In doing so, analysts could say how the working class must believe in hard work and put aside their own personal desires in order to make ends meet. Furthermore, analysts could undermine the belief in optimism and the existence of an absolute American Dream. Yes, the American Dream is correct when it says that hard work leads to success. Yet, it is not that simple. Encouraging hard work is admirable, but expecting it to take everyone to the top of the ladder is foolish. For example, not everyone will live the life of a millionaire. If the American Dream is foolproof then why is it that not everyone is a millionaire? Why does there exist such a disparity between the rich and the poor? And lastly, why does the climb to the top seem to never end?

Unknown said...

Cadmiel Feliz
Blog Assignment One
Mr. Burgess Period 3
Part 1 of 2

The Jungle by Upton Sinclair mostly takes place in twentieth century Chicago. The turn of the century has brought a new wave of hard working ambitious immigrants willing to work anywhere to achieve the American dream. Sinclair does two main things in this novel. Sinclair introduces the difficult and arduous life of a poor immigrant family from Lithuania and also works to reach the stomachs of the American people by revealing the horrifying labor practices of the meat packing district in emerging cities.
At this point I am through chapter eighteen on page 188 of 357. I am a little bit behind schedule but I feel in great shape through the novel at this point because of how brilliantly well this novel has been written. When I first picked up this novel and decided to dedicate it as my research paper novel, I simply hoped to have fun. I had the simple curiosity of knowing what actually went on in these meat factories. In addition to this curiosity I have always been interested in the history of America and one day while I sat in my 8th grade history class my history teacher recommended the book to me. He told me I would be the type to like it and he’s correct. Although I must say, I expected this novel to be all about the disgusting conditions and cruel practices of the big time meat companies, I grew shocked when the lives of realistic people were introduced into the picture. I did not expect the sentimental and depressing aspect of the novel to take place. This novel not only exposes the foul practices of the meatpacking factories during the 20th century but also the even more distasteful lives of the immigrants who work in them. I am glad I chose this novel to read and I am tremendously excited to continue its discovery and analysis.
Even before reading this novel I expected a course load of imagery to be used by Sinclair and I was right. Sinclair, being a muckraker of his time, needed to help the citizens of America vividly visualize the crimes being done to their meats. This is why it was of tremendous importance that his imagery reached the hearts, minds, and stomachs of his readers. Sinclair’s use of imagery delineated the events that took place at the plants but his imagery also captured the difficult life of Jurgis and his family. A feeling of hopelessness and anguish came over me as I read on their situations. Sinclair not only uses imagery but also plenty of symbolism. We see many comparisons where Sinclair uses the animals to represent the immigrants on the factory. Symbolism also lies in the title of this work. Sinclair’s use of the word “Jungle” suggests that in order for these immigrants to survive they must behave as if they lived in a Jungle where every day is an incessant struggle for survival. Sinclair not only looked to expose these evils through his novel but he also symbolically took jabs at the economic integrity of America during this time. Sinclair did not appreciate the abuse of the working class and sought to expose the evils of capitalism.

Unknown said...

Up to this point the plot has been a sad one it seems like nothing can go well for Jurgis and his family. In the beginning Jurgis and his wife Ona marry. Accompanied by Antanas, Teta Elzbieta, Jonas, Marija, and Ona's six stepbrothers and sisters they arrive in Chicago with hopes of becoming rich and bettering themselves. Once they arrive in America they discover the tough circumstances they must face every day. Thankfully Jurgis finds a job quickly due to his size and strength. They are introduced to the stockyards and even though the conditions are tough they have no choice but to carry on. As the adults find jobs they grow tired of the tenement they live in and decide to move out into a house now that four of the adults have steady jobs. They are able to put a down payment on a small house with only four rooms. Soon after as the winter soon approaches they discover by a neighbor that in reality the down payment of their house guarantees nothing and if they miss any payments they will basically get kicked out without remorse. Ironically when they receive this information the chaos occurs. Jurgis’s father dies of lung disease, Ona is about to have a baby, and Marija loses her job for some time. Ona later gives birth to Antanas. The family holds on until another wave of calamities occurs. Jurgis’s tendon falls out of place and he is forced to stay home for a few months. The children are later forced to go out into the city and sell newspapers to help make ends meet. Kristoforas also dies of a surprising sudden illness. Later, Ona starts displaying unusual behavior. She began behaving weirdly and somewhat shady. It turns out she had been sexually taken advantage by her boss and she did not make it home at times because she was forced by her boss Connor to be a prostitute at the brothel. When Jurgis found out the news he grew outraged and tried to kill Connor. This fit of rage only set him up for prison and time away from his family. In jail Jurgis meets an interesting college man who befriends him. After that he goes to court and suffers and unfair and bogus trial. The judge believes everything Connor says and doesn’t even let Jurgis speak. With the language barrier and social structure at play, Jurgis has no chance at getting any justice. Stanislovas later brings Jurgis loads of more terrible news and Jurgis grows even more angry and bitter. When Jurgis finally gets out of Jail he comes to his house and encounters a new family. He’s astonished and learns they were evicted. He then goes to their prior tenement and he finds Ona giving birth to a premature baby. Luckily, due to the pity of others he recollects enough money to go out in search of a midwife.
The Marxist Approach to The Jungle seems very interesting and applicable to Sinclair’s portrayal of life for the immigrant. In analyzing The Jungle Marxist critics would focus on the social class the work claims to represent, the social classes the characters work to represent, the way different characters from different classes conflict, and the values this work seems to reinforce. Marxist critics would definitely look into the struggle families like Jurgis’s face every day. Who’s the cause for their incessant ills, and why can’t they ever rise above their suppression? The Marxist critic will also ask for what the work says in regard to the meaning and message sent to the common reader of the time.

Unknown said...

Part 3 of 3
Marxist critics would use key characters like Jurgis to represent the innocent immigrant of the time who because of the evil and suppressive system becomes of simple use to the powerful oppressors. Marxist critics would also direct their attention to foil characters like Stanislovas who remain abused not only by the powerful bosses who abuse all workers and treat them like the cattle they process but also by the poor because as a child he has no voice. Stanislovas would surely be of analytical worth because of his tragic life and even more tragic death. An event of glaring importance to a Marxist critic would also be the court hearing of Jurgis after attacking Connor. Clearly we see Connor symbolizing the superior oppressor with no regard to justice or morals. Justice disregards the pleas of Jurgis and completely shunned his needs and solely entertained the statements made by Connor without challenge. The symbolism used by Sinclair would also be of tremendous use to the Marxist critic. Examples of symbols include the cattle and swine in regard to the workers, specific characters like Connor which point to the suppressing upper class, and the family house which symbolizes the elusive and escaping American dream.