Discussion Board: Nineteen Nineteen

The following discussion board was created as a place for current Honors English Four students to share their thoughts and experiences reading Nineteen Nineteen. Students are required to post their thoughts and experiences twice a week throughout the research paper process.  

 

3 comments:

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anonymous said...

Part 1


When I initially began 1919 by John Dos Passos I thought that since I understood the structure (or lack thereof) and had just studied the World War 1 era in class, that it would be a relatively quick read. However, once I began I found I had to supplement my reading with extra research as to the vernacular and obscure events of that epoch which seem irrelevant now but, were paramount then. Because of this I am extremely behind schedule (page 164) yet completely immersed in the world Dos Passos created.

The extra research has actually been fascinating as it's exposed me to works by Debs, Diogenes, and Steffens. Kipling's work, The Man Who Would Be King, appears first in John Reed's biography and then again in the tale of Dick Norton. Both men went through a transformation while studying at Harvard and Dos Passos made a point to highlight Kipling's book as an representative (of literature) agent of the radical change that occurs in both of these characters.

I love history, I love social commentary and I love a good story. Despite the presence of these three elements in 1919, the thing I appreciate most of all in 1919 is Dos Passos's style of writing. He doesn't paint a picture through description but by conveying a feeling. Through the placement of letters and spaces, lack of punctuation, and the segmentation of the 'chapters' Dos Passos all come together to make 1919 read not as a novel but as slice of life- a movie on paper.

It starts with a newsreel (macro view of America and the world) and heads straight into the personal world of Joe Williams, followed by the Camera Eye that gives a slightly personal yet disconnected look at the war through snippets of strangers' lives. Then a short biography on Jack Reed who lives and dies in the span of 4 pages, after which it is quickly back to Joe Williams (this time Dos Passos delves into his story). Then bam!- after 50 or so pages of Joe, a completely disconnected yet relevant Newsreel. This pattern (immersion-newsreel-camera eye-impersonal yet related story-immersion) continues = allowing 1919 to feel not like a novel, but like life.

In life the tribulations of one are but one of thousands if not millions- how can a sailor getting jailed and falling in love be more important than "the war to end all wars"? Dos Passos's answer: it cannot, it is not, but it should be. We slowly see the progression of the war and the increasing influence it has on the lives of our protagonists (Williams, Eveline, and Dick) by steering their lives unto unlikely paths paved by war.

In the beginning America has not yet entered the war, when Joe Williams deserts his ship in Havana and goes aboard a Scottish merchant ship headed to England as A.B. worker (low ranking sailor). Once near England, the Captain believes Joe to be a spy, since he has no papers, and hands him to the British police (probably so as not to have to pay him). During Joe's incarceration he meets another mistakenly held, yet much richer, American merchant who later tells the American Consulate that Joe is being held unlawfully. A representative from the American consulate arrives at the jail and gives Joe a ticket for a ship headed to America, on which he befriends a young sailor named Will Stirp. Once in Norfolk, Will introduces Joe to Della and they instantly hit it off and she becomes "his girl". They eventually get married right before he goes off to sea again with Captain Perry as a third mate (over his previous AB status).

Anonymous said...

Part 2


Next we get the story of Eveline Hutchinson, a young, innocent, and talented preacher's daughter from Chicago. As her story progresses, she becomes increasingly radical in her political views and liberal in her personal morals. She falls in love easily, quickly, and (so far) with all of the wrong men. After having affairs with three different men, she joins the Red Cross and heads to France. All the while, she has forgotten her original dreams of becoming an artist in the midst of her men and the war.

The biography of Jack Reed, a good, honest journalist from Harvard precedes and foreshadows that of Dick's, as in it he becomes increasingly radical throughout his studies and through his coverage of the war (he ends up dying in Smolny covering the Bolshevik Revolution). A good, All-American type middle class boy, Dick Norton works his way up through pseudo-hard work and schmoozing and gets sponsored by a previous employer to attend Harvard. At Harvard he becomes close friends with Ned, and like Reed becomes opposed to the war (for different reasons, but opposition nonetheless) and then joins the Red Cross to avoid another year studying at Harvard and heads off to France.

In analyzing 1919 new historicism critics would focus on the consideration of traditionally marginalized minorities such as the socialists, radicals, and anarchist of whom many were jailed or otherwise silenced during the war for their opposition and then feared and hunted after the war. Dos Passos gives socialists, radicals, and anarchists a back story and shows how they came to their beliefs through their stories he also portrays them as freedom fighters versus the age old assumption that all liberals and radicals are anti-America.

New Historicism critics would also focus on the critiques of politicians (in the Teddy Roosevelt biography) and the vernacular from that era (i.e. bully meaning cool) the meaning of which has changed since Dos Passos wrote 1919(i.e. bully now commonly refers to abuse someone). Critics would also tackle the seemingly contradictory critique of both the war effort (Dick's belief in pacifism) and America's refusal to enter the war (Joe Williams on the Scotch ship).