Discussion Board: The God of Small Things
The following discussion board was created as a place for current Honors English Four students to share their thoughts and experiences reading The God of Small Things. Students are required to post their thoughts and experiences twice a week throughout the research paper process.
4 comments:
When I thought about what a research paper entailed, I remembered it as something that would include reading an awful book that I would never willingly pick up. This year, however, as I picked up Arundhati Roy’s copy of The God of Small Things, I realized that this novel was not just another research paper book. I’m currently on chapter 15 of 21, and so far, I can’t think of a better novel to write about.
This novel, although great, still disappointed me in the beginning. The novel holds no solid plot, but instead compiles a series of scenes, flashbacks, and experiences. Because of this, it becomes confusing and takes a significant amount of time to get through. The backbone of the novel is simply a family traveling to the airport, and their stop to see the Sound of Music. The first chapter, about 40 pages long, nothing but description after description, and word after word. The entire chapter describes the city, and the people, and almost nothing else. It talks about rain, and weather. However, the novel certainly picks up from there. The second chapter immediately starts as a flashback, but the reader learns about the mother and her traumatic experiences that ultimately lead to a divorce. We learn about the members of the family and what their cast is. The character’s cast level, and thus their level in society, grows as an incredibly important idea throughout the novel. The novel consists of characters from every cast level, and it becomes clear that those of high casts are envied while those of low casts shunned.
The next few chapters continue with scenes and flashbacks. Basically, A man molests Estha when they go see the Sound of Music, and that remains something that haunts him forever. Estha continues to worry that the man will come to find him any day. Later, Sophie Mol and her mother arrive at the airport, and immediately, Rahel feels as if everyone forgot about her. She spends a great deal of the novel worrying about how much her mother loves her, and if she deserves to feel loved. A character from the lowest cast, Velutha, is introduced, and immediately, skepticism about him grows because of his cast. Although significantly older than Estha and Rahel, they still consider him their best friend.
In examining this novel, a feminist critic would most likely focus on the treatment of women in the novel. Right from the second chapter, we see the husband offering his wife as tribute in order for him to keep his job. The wife, when she refuses, suffers a beating and tormenting. They would focus on the social system where men always lie at the top. They can beat their wives and children, just like Ammu’s dad beat her when she went back for her boots. Sometimes, however, Baby Kochamma takes on the traits of a man. She acts selfish and thinks of herself at the top. She feels that she has a right to tell others how to behave. Feminine critics would also focus on that.
A New Criticism Critic would focus more on the themes presented throughout the novel. The theme of social class grows more prominent throughout the novel. Velutha, for example, lies in the untouchables, the lowest cast. Him and his father cannot even enter the house when they came to deliver mangoes. The idea of identity also grows as a theme that New Critics would focus on. Rahel, after hearing her mom say that people can love each other less, questions everything. In every situation, she questions whether or not her mother still loves her.
Overall, I can safely say that I picked a very admirable novel. It continues to impress me, and I cannot wait to finish.
The Booker Prize winning novel, The God of Small Things by Arundhati Roy is an entrancing book which captures many aspects of the world such as society and family. I am currently behind on schedule but that is due to the fact that this book is hard to read in several small sittings or even one whole. To be completely candid, I did not have very high expectations for this book. In my mind, whenever it comes to reading a research paper novel I always expect to have to force myself to get absorbed into something mundane. I thought that this novel would be just another typical book that was trying to portray a message about the world, almost working as a rebellion, like many other research paper novels I have read. Instead of being a dull classic novel, however, this book captured my interest because of several features included in it. To start off, I like how the book is organized. It tells each character’s story separately, giving the reader much insight into the lives of each individual, treating them all as equally important; whereas in reality, there are only two which need to be focused upon. The book doing this also gives the reader a lot of insight into the development of the plot and background of the characters and how the current situation comes to be. I also like how every character’s story is so different and they each have such unique personalities, but in the end they are able to meet at a commonplace. What also makes this novel appealing is Roy’s use of literary techniques. Throughout the novel, she uses a myriad of similes and metaphors, which seem to be her main point of interest when it comes to using literary devices. She is able to come up with several for just one character, seemingly for every action they carry out and any description that can be made about them. She also uses a lot of symbolism and allegory that relate to the setting, theme, and characters themselves. Until now, the plot is not definite, however the story has been centered on the stories of the characters, outlining each ones lives in scary detail. It goes through the flashbacks and current situations of each one’s and looks into their personalities.
The book would fall under two schools of literary criticism which would be Marxist and Historical/Biographical (pertaining to the characters, not the author). Since the novel focus’s a lot on the development of each character all the way from their childhood to adulthood entailing their journey across many places, the book could fall under historical criticism. The Marxist approach would be applicable because the story also narrows in a lot on society, especially aspects of it such as the cast system. For example, there are things in the novel such as “love laws,” which declare who is allowed to love who based of societal status and wealth. This novel could answer questions that concern the battle between the lower and upper classes and the politics of society, which Roy seems to be very concerned with because it was the truth of the matter in India as well.
So far, this novel has impressed me more than I ever imagined it would and has given me the ability to think of it in larger terms than I would ever think about a book.
When a seventeen year old is handed a list of books and allowed to choose which one to write about, she would be expected to read through and carefully pick her potential research paper novel. But in my case, I chose my book in part because of recommendations, and in part because of a whim. And despite being behind my schedule, nearly halfway through the book, I can see the genius in Roy’s novel.
I must admit, the choppiness and confusing chronology of the book put me off at first. It took a while to get used to it, and even longer to realize how I needed to read it: slowly, not missing a detail. Roy’s story of the two twins is so laced with symbolism and foreshadowing that by skimming through a couple paragraphs you will miss so much of the story. Each flashback holds heavy influence on the characters, Estha and Rahel in particular. It opens in Ayemenem, a sleepy village home to the “dizygotic twins,” Estha and Rahel. The emotional and physical separation of the “special breed of Siamese twins,” ensues through flashbacks of how these now 31 year old siblings came to be.
Through a scattered chain of events and memories, we learn the backstory of the characters. Ammu, Estha and Rahel’s mother, married on a whim to a man whose sparkle came from the liters of alcohol slushing around in his stomach. She left him, bringing with her Estha and Rahel, who are doomed in society having a divorced mother. Even in the family, she is almost detested. However, her relationship with her children is one typical of the culture: firm, yet loving. Baby Kochamma, an irritated, hateful woman, was once a beauty who held a fleeting romance with an Irish minister. He left the village, and she converted, entering a convent and vainly trying to win her love’s heart. Defeated, her mind turned to gardening and very recently to television, an addiction she shares with Kochu Maria, the servant. We learn, too, that Pappachi and Mammachi’s relationship held unsuccessfulness similar to Ammu and Baba’s.
Estha and Rahel, growing up amongst the confusing drama of the adulthood, continued to thrive. Rahel saw the world through rose-colored glasses and Estha sang innocent songs on endless car rides. The beginning of their drifting, however, may have occurred when they went to the theatre and Estha was molested by a man selling refreshments. Rahel, that day, became under the impression that her mother loved her less. With the death of Sophie Mol, their cousin, they were physically separated and therefore gradually evolved into separate identities. Rahel off to America, marrying and divorcing, and back to her sleepy village. Estha became quiet, scarred, almost mute, and shut off from the world. More narration and flashbacks will in hope shed light on the twins’ more current situations.
Through a Feminist perspective, one would possibly focus on the role of women and the devastating effects of social taboos: converting, divorcing, just speaking her mind. The differences between men and women in the novel seem to equal their similarities, a strange perspective told from a “chauvinistic nation.” It would be interesting to delve into the deeper meanings between the roles of men and women in the novel, and look closely at Estha and Rahel, being equals despite their gender difference. Also, Rahel’s attitude contrasts Estha’s, him being the quieter one inclined to cleanliness. The differences in expectations and roles between the two genders would be an interesting subject for one who takes the Feminist perspective.
If you had asked me my opinion of the novel one or two chapters in, I would have recommended you not read it, for fear of a dull introduction. But as I have read further into the novel, I can accurately judge the novel for what it is. The novel is capable of entrancing its reader, and giving him or her reason to think about the bigger picture, and I’m eagerly waiting for its conclusion.
At first I was not impressed with this novel, as the author goes into great detail in most passages and the plot was slow. It mainly talked about uninteresting descriptions of things such as the weather. Although the novel consists of flashbacks and the plot jumps around to different times in each of the characters’ lives, after a couple chapters it became easy to keep up with the storyline. I was not enthusiastic to read this book, as I was prepared for another forced research paper novel I would have to read. Moreover, the storyline moved around the death of a little girl, so it was depressing from the beginning. Once I got deeper into the plot, however, the hidden meanings unraveled and I became interested in Roy’s characters. We learn the different conflicts surrounding each family member. As the novel continues, the reason behind Sophie Mol’s death and the downfall it causes to the people around her unfolds. Every character, all from different castes, is connected to her death in some way. I like how Roy tells the story in flashbacks and in different time frames. It breaks the novel up into pieces and the reader must put them together to discover the whole story. Although it is confusing at times, as I read further into the novel I feel like I am putting a puzzle together. I’m currently on chapter 16 out of 21 and I’m really enjoying this novel.
From a Marxist criticism, we see a lot of the caste system throughout the novel. It deals a lot with reputation. For instance, when Velutha’s father feels that his son’s decision to have an affair with Mammachi’s daughter will cause the family shame, he offers to kill his own son with his bare hands. Moreover, we also see the forbidden love between Velutha and Ammu, because of their different statuses. It is clear that Roy criticizes the caste system and how it limits love.
Post a Comment