Discussion Board: Johnny Got His Gun

The following discussion board was created as a place for current Honors English Four students to share their thoughts and experiences reading Johnny Got His Gun. Students are required to post their thoughts and experiences twice a week throughout the research paper process. 

 

10 comments:

MrAsia said...

Part 1 of 2

Johnny Got His Gun is one of the most depressing novels that I have ever read. Being able to set my own schedule was a godsend, as I don’t think that a regimented, gradual timetable would have been effective for this novel. The only effective way to attack this novel is to sit down and trudge through large portions at a time. While wildly dark and morbid, it is not unlike a car wreck – no matter how horrible or disturbing, it is impossible to look away.

I was not unwarned about the novel’s gloomy tone, but I don’t think any level of cautionary advice could have properly prepared me for Johnny Got His Gun. It’s like being told, “It’s sad when a relative dies.” Of course it’s sad when a relative dies, and while intellectually one may understand, that warning does little to prepare one for the coming grief. I’ve come to see that, while the concept of a man having all of his limbs amputated and his face obliterated is depressing in and of itself, what is truly heartbreaking is Joe’s gradual realization that he has lost everything. Knowing full well what he has lost when he has yet to comprehend it is indescribable. I’ve never been so emotionally distraught over a book before.

I have something of a love-hate relationship with this book. Much like the Jersey Shore, it is simultaneously enthralling and painful. In almost a masochistic way, I “enjoy” (and I use the word loosely) reading this novel. It is certainly a unique experience. I don’t think that I regret my choice of novel, but I imagine that it’s too early to say.
The plot reads like a series of unfortunate events (lower case). He details the death of his father, his departure for war, the girl that he left behind and, much later, his new year’s celebrations from years past. These flashbacks provide a stark contrast to his dismal thoughts. He comes to terms with his condition, gradually realizing that he has lost everything. And, with nothing but his thoughts to keep him sane, he delves into some very serious topics, such as the nature of war, suffering, and his reflections on war.

MrAsia said...

Part 2 of 2

Johnny Got His Gun can be analyzed critically via many different schools of thought, but I believe it is best examined through the eyes of a Reader-response critic. Reader-response is a very versatile school, as anybody can examine literature from that school. A reader-response critic might say that Joe’s suffering, while tragic, isn’t the most heartrending part of the novel. They might acknowledge the larger tragedy, which is the war itself. Joe finds that the war was not his to fight. The powers that be dictate these engagements, and bring about these wars, at the expense of the average man. The Joes of this world.

Johnny Got His Gun is an unusual novel. The narrative is lackluster, and the plot is uninteresting. Even the characters are unlikable. But this sort of book is not read for its riveting tale or its relatable characters. Its single true redeeming feature is its social commentary. It was scathing. It draws sympathy to those afflicted by war, and brings doubt upon the establishments that cause it. I am interested to read the remainder of the novel. If nothing else, I should at least see how awful life can be.

Unknown said...

When I initially decided to read Johnny Got His Gun, I received warning about the seriousness of the novel. Anyone who thought the novel would turn out a hard-hitting war story would be disappointed, I was told. This has proven true, as halfway through the novel, fast-paced action appears scarce. This does not, however, mean that the novel lacks meaning. The first half of Johnny Got His Gun stimulated deep thinking about time and gratefulness for me. The novel begins with a flashback to Joe’s father’s death. At this point, the reader knows very little about Joe’s condition. What the reader does know, however, is that death is difficult to deal with. Author Dalton Trumbo establishes a sense of sympathy from the reader towards Joe before even fully disclosing his condition. Soon after this flashback, Joe experiences another. It becomes evident that memories will serve as the primary means of storytelling. The next memory jumps back to Joe’s childhood. In a way, the novel utilizes a stream of consciousness, as Joe’s memories are unsystematic and sporadic. This can be expected, I suppose, from someone whose only tool lies in thinking about the past.

After several more daydreams about the past, Joe begins to detail what it feels like to experience living in his state of health. Chapter Five seems particularly striking in this regard. In the chapter, Joe is floating on the river, and eventually sinks to the bottom of the river. Without arms and legs, he is unable to even put up a fight. Without arms and legs, he is unable to struggle. The narrator says, “He drowned without a struggle because he couldn’t struggle. He didn’t seem to have anything to struggle with” (Trumbo 59). This passage stood out to me because most people fear “the struggle.” They fear having to fight for something, and I am no different. Joe no longer possesses the ability to do this, and he longs for it. The passage made me realize that some people would trade everything they have for what seem like dreadful conditions to me.

One thing I noticed regarding this novel pertains to the way the narrator delivers each sentence. To make the novel seem more like a thought process rather than spoken words, Trumbo implemented a Flowers for Algernon-esque delivery. Though, initially, this appears as only a bother, it adds a unique voice to the narrator. In analyzing Johnny Got His Gun, the Reader-Response theory of criticism jumps to the forefront. Thought the main issue plaguing Joe is his physical condition, the larger issue at hand is the reason for his condition. Joe questions whether he was an important part of the war at all. He realizes that the war would have ultimately ended up no differently had he chosen not to participate. Critics would also be quick to analyze Joe’s questioning of the doctors. Joe wonders if he is seen as a trophy of success for doctors, since they managed to keep him alive (at a hefty cost). The second half of the novel should help me to answer more questions relevant to a Reader-Response analysis.

Brenick Anudon said...

Johnny Got His Gun shows just how much life can suck for the average Joe. I have heard that it is a very sad novel, and after reading a portion, I see the reason behind it. Right away, Dalton Trumbo introduces his novel with death, which will be a prevalent motif throughout. The first chapter entitled ‘The Dead’, shows the death of Joe’s father. A few sequences later, it is revealed to be a flashback. Throughout the novel, the Joe’s fate is slowly unraveled after a painfully slow plot progression. Much of the book’s setting takes place in the character’s mind, particularly flashbacks. They are triggered by what Joe feels while he is in bed. For instance, when he realizes his arm has been amputated, his mind takes him to memories of his fiancĂ©e. The soldier happened to be at the wrong place and at the wrong time, receiving a bomb that annihilated pretty much his whole existence. Unfortunately for him, he survived. Joe’s mental and physical suffering immediately garner’s the reader’s sympathy. Further, as his life story is laid out for the reader, reader’s have no option but to feel sorry for the guy. His upbringing embodies the typical American. The flashbacks of his mother baking and singing in the kitchen to his early love drama are all too real to just about anyone. When all of this is stripped away from him, pain and suffering takes their place. While the whole concept of a man in limbo between life and death initially seemed wildly interesting, it loses its appeal when the plot moves as fast Joe’s legs- which doesn’t move at all. Trumbo places atrocities upon atrocities on his main character’s figure to depict the horrors of war. There is really nothing more beyond this. By the end of the first few chapters, I think I got his whole anti-war purpose.
There are always multiple ways to analyze a novel but looking at this under the lenses of New Criticism would be best. For a novel that pretty much goes nowhere in terms of plot and action, critics should opt to read the text very closely. At a glance, the story is about the incredible and tragic events that occur with a soldier hanging on for dear life. On a profound note, underneath all of flashbacks, lies Trumbo’s message. Trumbo’s purpose with this novel was to display his opposition to war. Much like Joe’s physical state, he makes it clear that war is atrocious. For example, his attitude towards World War II is portrayed when his character says, “Oh why the hell did you get into this mess anyhow? Because it wasn’t your fight Joe” (Trumbo 25). New Criticism would provide a deeper insight that connects Joe and Dalton Trumbo.

Unknown said...

Johnny Got his Gun by Dalton Trumbo explores the depth of one of the most horrific possibilities in war, being trapped in a senseless state with your own mind. The novel completely meets my expectation as a depressing novel that does not fail to make the reader experience a sense of guilt and tragedy. It demonstrates a pure feeling of the destructive aspects of war and the toll it has inflicted upon people like Joe Bonham where everything can be lost in a flash. In some cases, the novel may even exceed its fictional genre because it pin points the reality of one’s struggle to stay sane while trapped in his empty world. Thus far the novel has been quite interesting for both its sad and joyful moments. The sadness of such a novel surrounds the helpless sensations of his lonely mind and his inability to associate the difference between reality and his dreams. Happiness becomes discovered through the memories of the past in which he remembers the laughter and warmth of his family and friends. The novel embraces the suffering of Joe Bonham after being decimated with injuries causing him to be disabled, losing most of his senses and his arms and legs, afterwards being forced the live through death with only his mind. Consistently each chapter goes back and forth his mind as memories and reality. He remembers his father’s death, childhood memories, the time back in Sale City, the job at the bakery with his friends and most recently the war and his girlfriend Kareen. The times where he is awake in reality resembles hell, he cannot stand himself being alone and his cries of being released from the feeling of being “drowned” does not become fulfilled. However in Book II The Living, he finally begins to adapt to his new life and finds significant comfort through being “very busy” in his mind with the discovering the sense of time, the comfort of nurses and his memories of those in the war.
Throughout the novel there are demonstrations of Marxist criticism, with the writer developing a key focus on war. If Johnny Got His Gun was accepted and believed it would benefit the idea of life in general. The theme of war and its devastating consequences can only be described as tragic, nothing less because of the great semblance to all risk soldiers must give up when going to war. They risk their lives, bodies and sanity for the simple idea of being patriotic which may seem meaningless to those that have things they value more. In life, the ability to live is valued above all else, without it people cannot function, express their feelings or do what they love. What the writer presents to the reader resembles the natural instinct people have and generally should relinquish anything to live, whether it is experiencing freedom to enduring great suffering as anything is better than death. During many sequences of the novel it can depicted that the author represents a lower class view. The author often puts the main character in situations where he sinks into regretful or humiliating state in which he had experienced or within the present. In one of the memories of Joe Bonham he remembers the life of his childhood and his father able to provide for his family through his garden. However, his father appears to be a failure simply based on his insufficient salary to support his family completely. Such fact plays a significant part because of the main characters view where his family was able provide happiness to their family and should not have been judged simply based on money. Critics would simply focus upon the main themes of the novel and question why is there such a strong belief that believing in personal values such as honor or patriotism may not be worth a life? This surrounds an opinionated stance that ultimately suggests that the author holds view that based on Joe Bonham there should be a limit to how much people should risk before it is pointless to be fighting for something other than life itself.

ShafanKhan said...

I am not an avid reader but I do enjoy books. I usually occupy myself with the countless amount of responsibilities that are hoisted upon my shoulders and do not get the time to delve deep into many novels. Sometimes books are the best escape, Johnny Got his Gun by Dalton Trumbo was one I was ready to put down as soon as I’d read a few pages. Although my mind was telling me to go put the book down and watch the Lakers game, my subconscious told me to not let go of it. My subconscious did me good. As I freely navigate myself through the novel, the gloomy and dark setting gives me a different perspective on situations and life. Sometimes the only way to understand someone else is to know how it would feel to be in his or her shoes. As I read this book without having to worry about bookmarks or annotations it allowed me to completely grasp each and every word that was being thrown at me. I learned about the horrific consequences of modern warfare and the way Trumbo depicts the scenes makes it all the more enjoyable. What is there to enjoy from a novel that seems only dark and gloomy you may ask? Well if the author does a well enough job it is as if you’re on a journey alongside the characters. Although I’d love to sit and completely explain how the novel affects me emotionally, I think it would be apropos to discuss how the context actually pleases me.
I’ve been able to stick to my schedule and I’m near the end of my novel, the reason for this is because having the opportunity to dive into the life of a radically different individual excites me. I like accompanying Joe in his flashbacks, sometimes I can relate and sometimes all I can do is read the words. The beginning of Johnny Got His Gun consists mainly of Joe's flashback’s, which I believe serve towards a larger purpose in the theme. The flashbacks are often sad and dismal moments of Joe’s life which have no use in being recalled. The scenes include nerve wrecking things such as people leaving and never coming back. This is when we first realize that Joe is not physically trapped but actually mentally. However hard he tries he will never be able to free himself from the bondage of his own mind.

Joey Ikuss said...

“Johnny Got His Gun,” by Dalton Trumbo is interesting to say the least. I am on chapter nine in the story, which unfortunately is behind my schedule. I plan on finishing it all this week. The novel starts off with the protagonist, Joe, waking up in a kind of trance. He immediately starts to dream and remembers some key things that happened in his life. Specifically, he remembers the day when his father died, and some scenes he knew about his father’s and mother’s romance. At the end of each scene, a different sound or thought hangs over Joe’s mind. Joe keeps remembering things from his childhood, until he eventually realizes that he was wounded in war, losing all his limbs and senses except the ability to feel. In one memory, he says how he ended up in a war that had nothing to do with him. From memories of work and his previous love life, Joe begins to piece together his life up to the war, realizing the extent of the damage to his body. He remembers almost every sad and scary moment from his life, feeling complete and utter loneliness after each memory.
So far, I have enjoyed the book. I like how there is a lot more about Joe’s past life as opposed to just what happened in the war. After reading some descriptions I figured it would just be a war story but there is so much more to it that I like. Trumbo’s use of such strong, vivid details really keeps me interested and helps me connect to Joe and really feel his emotions. Also, I love what Trumbo does at the end of each flashback. He has a sound or image just stink into Joe’s head which all can seem to be satires of something. Examples of this are the phone ringing, Joe thinking he is drowning, and the rat. These really connect Joe’s past memories to what he is feeling now and serve as satires of various things.
Historical Criticism is definitely one of the possibilities for this story. There is so much going on that connects to all aspects of society in Joe’s and Trumbo’s life. There are glimpses of the everyday life, like work, camping, and romance, and the war that shook the world at that time. Like I said, the images at the end of the memories seem to be the perfect ways to implement this satire, as they are an image of the time that sticks into the readers head. Critics would focus on these, along with the sharp detail Trumbo uses to refer to this book as a Historical Criticism.
Another possible take on this story is that of a Marxist Critic. These critics take the ideas of the author and use them in the story. As it turns out, Trumbo was a communist, and was jailed for refusing to answer questions in an Un-American Activities Survey. He could be using these thoughts and actions as a communist, and show the flaws in the current society. Later on in the story, he may be taking these flaws and then showing how his communist ideas could replace them and make society better. I will need to read more of the story to figure this out.
Overall, I am really enjoying the book. There is a lot more depth to the story than I originally intended and look forward to finishing it as soon as possible.

Unknown said...

For the research paper assignment I chose to read Johnny Got His Gun by Dalton Trumbo. Throughout the novel the main character, Joe, tries to educate the reader of the results to modern day war. From the beginning, I was pretty unfamiliar with the novel aside from the fact that it discussed a soldier dealing with the struggles after fighting in World War II, using both flashbacks and present tense. At page 200, I have about forty pages remaining which puts me a little behind schedule but I will most likely finish by this weekend. Although Johnny Got his Gun uses really dark language, I seem to like it. I really admire studying World War II and this book and the approach the author took differentiates from anything else I have read before. It can be confusing having to follow the tenses, but it has come easier throughout the whole. I’ve also come to notice a pattern: every flashback describes some kind of loss whether it recounts his father’s death at the beginning or his relationships with women. It meets my expectations because it’s very psychological, which I do not normally find myself reading. The only fail to my expectations includes the denial of Joe’s request: for his body to be presented as an exhibit for men around the world to see what war has done to him. If the doctor had allowed this to happen the book might have gone in a totally different direction, but otherwise it meets my expectations. With that, I enjoy this novel. It really creates detailed images whether gruesome or not, which makes the novel easier to understand. Also, the language used is really powerful to describe Joe’s struggle. When Joe says, “God give me rest take me away hide me let me die oh god how weary how much already dead how much gone and going oh god hide me and me peace” the hopelessness of Joe really comes across. I find it interesting to think that after Joe has lost almost all his limbs, most of his face, which impairs his sight, speaking abilities and hearing, he remains a believer in god.
A few literary devices that the author utilizes include flashbacks, metaphors and imagery. Based around flashbacks, almost every few pages switches over to his life before and during the war. This helps to understand Joe’s personality then and now. For example, Joe flashes back to a time when he and his father go camping. Joe invites a friend named Bill Harper along the way and the two of them go fishing, which results in the loss of his father’s fishing rod. During this whole excerpt Trumbo utilizes a great deal of imagery to recount the entire event. The author says “Each summer they came to this place which was nine thousand feet high and covered with pine trees and dotted with lakes,” which really places the reader into the scene imagining the whole trip. In reality Joe can’t see anything but his memories come across so vividly. Joe’s dad distinguishes a metaphor for this summer trip as the last time he and his son seek happiness together.
To this point, Joe has fallen victim to the terrors of World War II and he has basically lost everything that makes him a real man. He lies helpless in a hospital as a nurse comes in and out to check on him. He remains alive in his mind and remains determined to educate young men what war can do to a human. He eventually recognizes vibrations and begins using Morse code to communicate with the doctor and nurses. At first Joe tries killing himself by suffocation and sees no point in life but moves away from that idea as the story unfolds. He finds it hard to recognize his consciousness and unconsciousness as he recounts memories of his family, friends and second girlfriend Kareen.

Unknown said...

For the research paper assignment I chose to read Johnny Got His Gun by Dalton Trumbo. Throughout the novel the main character, Joe, tries to educate the reader of the results to modern day war. From the beginning, I was pretty unfamiliar with the novel aside from the fact that it discussed a soldier dealing with the struggles after fighting in World War II, using both flashbacks and present tense. At page 200, I have about forty pages remaining which puts me a little behind schedule but I will most likely finish by this weekend. Although Johnny Got his Gun uses really dark language, I seem to like it. I really admire studying World War II and this book and the approach the author took differentiates from anything else I have read before. It can be confusing having to follow the tenses, but it has come easier throughout the whole. I’ve also come to notice a pattern: every flashback describes some kind of loss whether it recounts his father’s death at the beginning or his relationships with women. It meets my expectations because it’s very psychological, which I do not normally find myself reading. The only fail to my expectations includes the denial of Joe’s request: for his body to be presented as an exhibit for men around the world to see what war has done to him. If the doctor had allowed this to happen the book might have gone in a totally different direction, but otherwise it meets my expectations. With that, I enjoy this novel. It really creates detailed images whether gruesome or not, which makes the novel easier to understand. Also, the language used is really powerful to describe Joe’s struggle. When Joe says, “God give me rest take me away hide me let me die oh god how weary how much already dead how much gone and going oh god hide me and me peace” the hopelessness of Joe really comes across. I find it interesting to think that after Joe has lost almost all his limbs, most of his face, which impairs his sight, speaking abilities and hearing, he remains a believer in god.
A few literary devices that the author utilizes include flashbacks, metaphors and imagery. Based around flashbacks, almost every few pages switches over to his life before and during the war. This helps to understand Joe’s personality then and now. For example, Joe flashes back to a time when he and his father go camping. Joe invites a friend named Bill Harper along the way and the two of them go fishing, which results in the loss of his father’s fishing rod. During this whole excerpt Trumbo utilizes a great deal of imagery to recount the entire event. The author says “Each summer they came to this place which was nine thousand feet high and covered with pine trees and dotted with lakes,” which really places the reader into the scene imagining the whole trip. In reality Joe can’t see anything but his memories come across so vividly. Joe’s dad distinguishes a metaphor for this summer trip as the last time he and his son seek happiness together.
To this point, Joe has fallen victim to the terrors of World War II and he has basically lost everything that makes him a real man. He lies helpless in a hospital as a nurse comes in and out to check on him. He remains alive in his mind and remains determined to educate young men what war can do to a human. He eventually recognizes vibrations and begins using Morse code to communicate with the doctor and nurses. At first Joe tries killing himself by suffocation and sees no point in life but moves away from that idea as the story unfolds. He finds it hard to recognize his consciousness and unconsciousness as he recounts memories of his family, friends and second girlfriend Kareen.

Unknown said...

I think an important point brought up includes Joe’s struggle to want to live or die. At times he begs for his life to end soon, or finds himself in a state of depression after thinking about times he was happy alongside his now deceased dad. But then he also wants his body to be seen around the world, sending out a message to all those who want to be a soldier. Based off of all of his thoughts, Freudian structure is used to determine whether his conscious or subconscious mind exists. Not even Joe realizes at times when his mind remains asleep, sedated or awake. Many critics would criticize the dark approach Trumbo takes to summarize one soldier’s life after World War II. At one time this anti-war novel was even banned for some time after it came out due to its controversy. From the publication of this novel, critics see it as both too shocking and a truth no one should know or an emotionally intense work that all should understand. A great deal of sexuality stands as well, whether between Kareen or descriptions of things such as the caretaking of Joe or even guns/bullets. This may be controversial to certain critics but really shows the psychological approach that the author used in making this novel powerfully gripping.