The following discussion board was created as a place for current Honors English Four students to share their thoughts and experiences reading My Name is Red. Students are required to post their thoughts and experiences twice a week throughout the research paper process.
3 comments:
Adam Ahmad Part 1 of 2
So far I am on Chapter 20 page 106 in the novel My Name is Red. The main narrative thus far is progressing at a vey slow and gradual pace as the first fifteen chapters were basically providing the reader with background information on Black’s life and the culture of sixteenth century Isanbul. The novel commences with Red’s (Effendi’s) spirit in purgatory describing his gruesome death to the reader. The reader learns that Effendi like many other Turkish miniaturists has been employed by the Sultan to paint beautiful pictures in an European Style. The miniaturists’, or the artists’, task however is perceived as being sacrilegious and offensive to Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) and the entire religion of Islam. Following this initial introduction to the nature of the novel, Pamuk provides the reader with narratives as told by Black (another miniaturist), Shekure, a street dog, Red’s murderer, a butterfly, a gold coin, and even a tree. Each chapter progresses the story and helps the reader understand the culture of sixteenth century Turkey. We are introduced to Black a miniaturist who was kicked out of his home for proposing marriage to his cousin Shekure and is forced to wander the world for twenty years. Upon his arrival in Istanbul he finds Shekure married to a soldier missing in action and a mother of two children. The next couple of chapters then consist of Shekure’s feeling for Black and vice versa.
The way Orhan Pamuk presents the story to the reader seems very strange to me as each chapter has a different main character and a different perspective on typical sixteenth century life in Istanbul. The novel so far did meet my expectations in structural respects; I oftentimes found it hard to connect to the story and its characters as each chapter varied in plot and insight. However, the novel is still very interesting, although Pamuk’s technique in presenting the story can be tedious and confusing at times. The actual plot of the novel captivates my attention as the mystery of Red’s death in the beginning of the novel speaks to my love for mystery novels. Despite the novel’s confusing layout, I am still enjoying the story. The novel as a whole in my opinion, contrasts the traditions and beliefs of the Old Islamic World to the New Western European culture. This comparison is universal to me because as a Muslim-American, I like the miniaturists in the novel find myself juggling the culture of my religious beliefs with the culture of the Western world. In that respect, the novel portrays a theme which is the struggle to uphold one’s religious and cultural beliefs while at the same time establishing a niche for oneself in society.
Adam Ahmad Part 2 of 2
Having read the first twenty chapters of the novel I think a formalist approach to the story would be an affective way towards analyzing the meaning of the story as a whole. Each chapter has its own unique symbols, perspectives, and characters and analyzing the novel through a formalist lens would provide the reader with more insight about the novel. As more and more Quranic allusions appear in the novel a formalist would as the question, what is the relationship between the plot of the novel and the mentioned surahs (Quranic passages) in the passage? Asking such question about religious allusions would allow the reader to grasp a better understanding of the nature and the meaning of the novel. Furthermore I believe that a formalist critic would also analyze the roles of the Dog, the Tree, the Butterfly, and the Murderer’s chapters in the novel as their inclusion in the progression in the plot can be perceived as being strange and out of place with the general plot of the novel. The addition of these seemingly unrelated characters can be perceived as symbols that criticize the culture of Ancient Islamic society. In addition, Black’s desire to reunite with Shekure in chapters 7 and 11 can be analyzed by psychological critic. A psychological critic would ask himself the question, what is Black’s motivation to build a relationship with his Uncle and Shekure despite being exiled from the family for twenty years? So far these two schools of thought would be perfect towards analyzing My Name is Red.
Hamza Shuja
I am reading My Name Is Red by Orhan Pamuk. I am into chapter twenty-two on page 119. So far, from what I have read, I am enjoying this book, but it is really different from anything I have read in previous years. The structure of the book is quite strange and makes it hard to follow the plot. Each chapter has a different narrator that tells the story from his or her point of view and shares his or her feelings with the reader. I expected the language to be a little more difficult but I did not expect some of the explicit content talked about, this book can get pretty detailed. I like the book for the most part, although some of the dialogue about the painting styles can get tedious as it is repeated over and over again. Furthermore, different chapters recount the same events from different points of view. In some cases, like when Shekure appears at the window, or Elegant Effendi’s funeral, the switch in narration can be intriguing and give good insight. It creates an obscure, mysterious atmosphere where the narrations are helping solve the mystery. Unfortunately, sometimes it just becomes tedious because the plot takes so long to unravel.
Pamuk uses a plethora of literary devices throughout the work. Flashbacks are a prominent device, especially in Shekure’s narrations. She remembers her husband and her time spent almost imprisoned by her brother in law Hassan, Black remembers his travels and his childhood, and the miniaturists remember their times as apprentices. Frame stories are also present when Black goes to the three masters to hear their stories. Out of all the devices however, Pamuk uses personification in the most outstanding way. Whole chapters are narrated by paintings of a tree, a dog and a coin. The paintings narrate what is going on around them, but more interestingly, they give insight on their feelings. They help us see what is going on at the psychological level around them.
So far, Black Effendi, a miniaturist like his uncle has just returned to Istanbul after twelve years. He left because he fell in love with his cousin, Shekure, and could not marry her. Now he has come back a grown man and his uncle, Enisthe Effendi, puts him to work investigating three great masters, Olive, Stork and Butterfly, for the death of a fourth, Elegant. Enishte suspects one of the three killed him. Enishte is also working on a top secret book for the Sultan in the Venetian style of painting in which the paintings are made under the cover of night by the masters.
If one was to analyze this book from a Psychoanalytical point of view, there is much to take from it. Each character, and even inanimate objects share their feelings and their stories and they sometimes address the reader directly which means they are conscious of the audience and can lie. The personification especially gives room for a psychological analysis of what the author is trying to say. Also, Freud’s theory of the Oedipus complex can be observed by the sexual desires of Shekure, Black, and Hassan. The vying of their mother’s attention between Orhan and Shevket can also be attributed to the Oedipus complex.
A New critic would also find much to work on in this novel. There is extensive use of literary devices like personification, frame story, flashback, metaphor, anecdote and on and on. The names of the masters, Stork, Olive, Butterfly and Elegant are points of interest because one of them is a murderer of the murdered Elegant. The title of the novel is My Name Is Red coming from the point of view of a color, again coming to personification. Also, the ability of each narrator to lie or morph the story gives much room for interpretation.
Post a Comment